This previous week, UFC 250 went down the place Amanda Nunes defend her featherweight title in dominant trend. Nevertheless, Nunes efficiency was overshadowed by the largest struggle within the sport proper now: the UFC vs. its greatest stars. Jorge Masvidal mainly declared battle on the UFC, Jon Jones is holding robust as effectively, and Conor McGregor “retired” but once more, most likely for comparable causes as the primary few occasions. So let’s discuss in regards to the state of this fighters union.
Do you assume between Jon Jones, Masvidal, and McGregor, that the UFC would let fighters unionize with out recourse? And do you assume between these three fighters, do any of them truly care about different fighters?
— William(Iron)Wheeler (@WilliamDWheeler) June 10, 2020
To paraphrase Ben Affleck in The City, “You ain’t ‘letting’ me do shit.” If someway a wholesome majority of the fighters within the UFC truly get their shit collectively and unionize, Dana can’t cease them – that’s unlawful.
Furthermore, if Jon Jones, Conor McGregor, and Jorge Masvidal truly did spearhead the creation of a UFC union, there wouldn’t be a lot Dana may do anyway. To not get all Eugene Debs on you however the energy of the UFC rests completely within the employees fingers, in a manner that’s much more pronounced than different companies. Give it some thought this fashion: most random companies can exchange any low to mid-level workers with out an excessive amount of fuss, and may exchange their highest degree workers, although it might be troublesome or expensive. In distinction, the UFC can exchange curtain-jerker fighters and even random mid-card expertise and be none the more severe for put on (in a grand sense) however changing headlining fighters with lesser expertise is far tougher, and changing high stars, is almost unattainable. If the UFC was truly good at promotion and star-building, perhaps these items could be simpler, however it’s truly horrible at that. So sure, the UFC model is the best advertising and marketing device the UFC possesses, however with out the highest fighters they nonetheless make a lot much less cash and with out the high-end fighters, that device turns into nugatory fast.
As as to whether Jones, Masvidal, or McGregor truly care about different fighters, I believe going with “nope” is a protected assumption. That’s to not say they need others to remain locked into low-paying purses however simply that they’re detached to the plight of anybody that isn’t them. Thankfully, they don’t want to present a single shit about anybody apart from themselves to acknowledge that unionization is of their greatest curiosity.
Conor McGregor is the largest star within the sport’s historical past, and simply essentially the most well-paid; he nonetheless will get a pittance of what an equal caliber begin in boxing would get. The maths right here is fairly easy: even when you get the lion’s share of 18% of the UFC’s income, you’re nonetheless not getting almost as a lot as when you received essentially the most cash from 50% of the UFC’s income. Conor can’t leverage the UFC into that a lot cash. Neither can Jon Jones or Jorge Masvidal or Nate Diaz or anybody else, by themselves. But when sufficient of them begin to lastly look greater than three toes in entrance of them, all of them can pressure the difficulty.
A rising tide lifts all boats. Possibly the fighters are lastly beginning to understand the tide has been low for many years.
Why do you assume it is so onerous for MMA fighters to get collectively and unionize? Is it as a result of they one another an excessive amount of as opponents first earlier than co-workers? Is it their politics or philosophy? Survival mentality in opposition to Dana?
— Wesley Hayato Dugle (@Pop_Wasabi) June 11, 2020
Initially, as a result of unions are a tough factor to get off the bottom within the first place. It’s important to generate a groundswell of curiosity and you’ve got to take action within the face of an employer who legally can’t forestall you from doing so, however has a myriad of how to present you bother. Have a look at the actual GOAT, Leslie Smith. Smith couldn’t make headway withe a Fighter’s Affiliation and was drummed out of the UFC on account of attempting. Technically, the UFC did nothing incorrect, however in actuality, Smith was booked in opposition to a fighter who missed weight, she refused to struggle, and the UFC paid her present and win cash and uncared for to re-sign her. The UFC, notoriously short-armed with paying win bonuses, paid this one out as a result of they knew in the event that they didn’t Smith would have extra grounds for a lawsuit, so they simply lower the verify and let her go to Bellator the place she wouldn’t fire up any extra bother for them.
Past that although, a fighter’s union has possible proved elusive as a result of the physique of individuals who would comprise it, are about as troublesome a bunch to get to comply with such an idea as there are on this world. By nature of their career, fighters are virtually completely self-interested and, given their quick profession window, largely wanting solely on the quick future. For many, combating is a ardour and as such, they’re prepared to take any cash in any respect to compete. Consequently, many additionally discover themselves in dire monetary conditions which suggests a reasonable $30Okay paycheck appears to be like extra like a lifeboat than bread crumbs. To not point out, all fighters are optimists and imagine they are going to be champ at some point after which, that’s after they’ll make the large cash! On high of that, ideologically, a majority of fighters within the UFC development in direction of anti-union sentiment. Mainly, getting fighters to unionize is like herding cats, when you have been doing so in a discipline the place catnip is unfold in all places, another person is actively attempting to stop you from doing so, and like half the cats are simply straight up saying “f*ck you”.
Nevertheless, there may be purpose to imagine perhaps this time issues might be totally different!
I wrote about this earlier this week however in brief, there are two key components that make now the almost definitely time in UFC historical past that fighters may lastly determine this shit out. First, fighters are actually vastly extra knowledgeable about what others make and what the UFC makes (trace, it’s much more than the fighters make), and second, the UFC’s cope with ESPN.
The clear, goal fact is that the UFC is ripping off the fighters. In case you don’t imagine that, you’re both fully uninformed or a bootlicker of the best order (Dana is rarely going to like you such as you need him to, transfer on). Making 18-20% of income is, on its face, absurdly low, ESPECIALLY given the hurt they threat by combating. Data is energy and the fighters are extra knowledgeable than ever.
And the ESPN deal offers the fighters a fair larger platform and sways issues additional of their favor. ESPN pays the UFC for content material and to be the house of their PPVs. They don’t give two farts within the wind in regards to the UFC’s backside line. ESPN makes extra money the higher the content material they obtain, as a result of extra folks will wish to watch, and thus they’re incentivized to push the UFC to make the most effective fights, which in flip means to pay fighters extra money to make them occur. ESPN can push this each immediately, by telling Dana to take action, and not directly, by giving Jorge Masvidal a serious platform to lambast the UFC’s draconian pay construction. Public opinion is a robust device, and the fighters have a possibility to leverage that proper now.
Will it occur? Odds are nonetheless not at this level. As a substitute of simply tacitly sitting out and Tweeting, you’d want an actual chief to emerge who can get the fighters engaged and create an actual motion. However perhaps at some point.
Do you assume the Nunes v Spencer struggle ought to have been stopped or was there no purpose to?
— Jo Blow (@MRvaronos) June 11, 2020
Amanda Nunes vs. Felicia Spencer ought to have completely been stopped, however not by the referee. Ever the skilled, Herb Dean did an excellent job in the principle occasion of UFC 250. Nunes beat Spencer pillar to publish (I scored the bout 50-42 Nunes for reference) however other than the top of the fourth spherical when Nunes had that choke in, Spencer was a minimum of attempting to struggle again for all of it. If Herb Dean had stopped it, nobody would’ve complained, given the one-sided nature of that specific thumping, nevertheless it wouldn’t have been the precise name. Dean’s job is to avoid wasting the fighter after they can now not intelligently defend themself, not mitigate an ass-kicking.
That job falls squarely on the nook, and boy did it fail. It’s been mentioned advert nauseum at this level however MMA corners are horrible at saving their very own fighters. Spencer doesn’t seem like majorly worse for put on due to it however sending her out for the fifth spherical was pure negligence. She had a zero % probability to win the struggle and a excessive probability of absorbing considerably extra injury. What’s the acquire? An ethical victory? Fighters might want that however it’s the corners job to know that ethical victories aren’t price half as a lot as misplaced mind cells. We’re not simply speaking about shortening careers, we’re speaking about shortening lifespans and it’s excessive time one thing modified in MMA.
Do U assume O Malley may very well be the Successor of Conor if he retains what’s doing contained in the Octagon when it comes to his expertise ?
— HONG KONG (@AbdullahShwihdi) June 11, 2020
Nobody goes to be “the following Conor McGregor” when it comes to star energy. No matter your emotions about him personally, the person is exclusive in his capacity to attract curiosity to MMA. Alongside that, the early phases of Conor’s UFC profession have been observe excellent. In case you had a time machine and did it over, Conor would nonetheless develop into a star and a champion, nevertheless it’s unlikely issues would go fairly as completely for him.
So it’s each statistically and simply logically unlikely O’Malley can replicate that success. Nevertheless, this child definitely has the potential to be an enormous star for the UFC. Individuals gravitate in direction of him and he has large expertise. He’s additionally combating in some of the thrilling divisions within the sport so if he retains progressing, the UFC may have a critical star on their fingers.
(Sidenote, I discover O’Malley fascinating as a result of although he’s his personal man, it’s apparent his fashion is closely influenced by McGregor. I at all times get pleasure from watching how new generations of fighters undertake hallmarks of well-known fighters earlier than them. I assure you O’Malley has watched hours and hours of McGregor footage.)
What do you assume the following matchup for Colby Covington might be?
— (@FrontLegKick) June 11, 2020
Do you assume the UFC owes it is viewers a reduction on PPVs due to the pandemic?
— Alex Scaffidi (@alexscaffidi_) June 11, 2020
Firstly, the UFC has owed its viewers a reduction for effectively over a decade. PPV is an outdated mannequin within the first place and charging $60+ for each occasion is freeway theft. In case you are a hardcore MMA fan who lives within the States, and who doesn’t take pleasure in any unlawful streaming providers, you might be paying the UFC is costing you roughly $800 a yr. That’s insane.
However, notably throughout this time, sure, the UFC must be scaling again the PPV worth and them not doing so is an indication of each their complete lack of creativity, and their abject desperation for income to repay their debt.
That is PR/Promotion 101. The UFC made an enormous fuss about being the primary ones again with reside sports activities and “we’re doing this for the followers”. Nice. However lots of their followers have been laid off as a result of coronavirus and $70 is considerably burdensome. Will they do it anyway? Certain, many will as a result of they don’t have anything else to do and it’s an oasis in a sports activities desert. However as an alternative wouldn’t or not it’s higher to decrease the value to $20, get much more purchase in from informal sports activities followers, and engender goodwill amongst your hardcore group by displaying solidarity with them throughout these troublesome occasions? Truthfully, it is a goddamn layup and the UFC can’t see the longterm payoffs as a result of they’re too busy centered on what’s proper in entrance of them. I suppose the fighters and the group are lots alike in any case.
Thanks for studying this week, and thanks for everybody who despatched in Tweets! Do you might have any burning questions on a minimum of tangentially associated to fight sports activities? You then’re in luck, as a result of you may ship your Sizzling Tweets to me, @JedKMeshew and I’ll reply them! Doesn’t matter in the event that they’re topical or insane. Get bizarre with it. Let’s have enjoyable.